Should the Jews pay taxes to Caesar?

Should the Jews pay taxes to Caesar?

Matthew 22:15-22

The Jewish rulers did not like the parables that Jesus told in Matthew chapters 21-22. They decided that they must stop Jesus now. The Pharisees believed the Law. It is strange that they joined up with the Herodians. The Herodians were a political group. They did not believe God's Law at all.

So, the Pharisees and the Herodians came to Jesus with a question:

  • Was it right to give taxes to Caesar?

If Jesus said ’Yes‘, he would disappoint many Jews. If he said ’No‘, the Romans could arrest him.

In reply, Jesus asked for a coin. He asked the people to describe the head on it. The head was Caesar‘s. He then said:

21 They replied, ‘It is Caesar's picture and Caesar's name.’

Jesus said to them, ‘So you should give to Caesar the things that belong to Caesar. And give to God the things that belong to God.’

Matthew 22:21 EasyEnglish Bible (EASY)

There is great wisdom in this short answer. Rulers should do what God wants. We should obey our rulers if their laws are not evil. Paul later writes more about this in Romans 13:1-7. Other New Testament writers also mention this subject. Men should pay the king what he deserves. But Jesus also said ’Give to God the things that belong to God‘. Jesus said that God is the greatest ruler. We must not keep back anything that belongs to him. Rulers on earth can demand much. But this means that there is a limit to their demands.

Jesus' reply has another meaning also. On the other side of the coin, there were words. They said that Caesar was a god. Clearly, Jesus was denying this.

The wisdom of this quick answer was surprising. Jesus‘ enemies went away. They could not answer what he said.